Is It Tough Love?

My daughter recently told me one of the girls in her class had a sister that died in a car crash. Tragic, yes? Then she said, “now her sister is in heaven.”

Ouch. I certainly didn’t expect to have this conversation with her so young – she is in kindergarten! Luckily, my daughters haven’t had to deal with loss yet, and so I haven’t really had to talk about it much. But her comment has had me thinking about how to approach it, and how to make it age-appropriate.

I have been hearing a lot recently about how religion offers comfort in times of loss, and it eases the feelings of despair and hurt that losing someone close can cause. I don’t doubt this to be true. But I also worry that by telling my children that someone is in heaven when they’ve died, that they aren’t going to learn real coping strategies for the inevitable loss and tough situations that happen during their lives.

Now, I’m definitely not an advocate for tough love in general. I admit to being a bit of a pushover…I just don’t like to see those little faces upset! My girls are 2 and 5, and up to this point, I have found the best way to teach them to act appropriately is just by modelling the right kind of behaviour. I am kind to others, compassionate, polite, and respectful. I make an extra effort to act this way in front of my girls, and for the most part they are very polite and well-behaved.

However, after saying all that, I do believe in tough love when it comes to these types of “hard topics.” I don’t believe in lying to my children to make things easier on myself. I touched on this a bit in my post about Santa Claus, and my philosophy stands with this subject as well. I am not doing my daughter’s any favours by shielding them from the reality of loss. When they are little, I can make sure to be there for them, and talk them through it. I know that as they grow up they WILL have to deal with varying types of loss – it is inevitable. I believe that honesty is always the best policy.

Kids in this younger age group take things very literally, so telling them that someone has gone to “a better place” or something to that effect will only result in confusion. They will take that to mean that death is a location, somewhere people can go, and maybe return from. They need to know that the person who has died is not coming back. Also, telling a kid that “God took your friend,” or it was “God’s will” that someone died could possibly be very scary and even more traumatizing for them then the actual loss.

So in the end I had a brief conversation with her about what it meant that her friend’s sister went to heaven. I explained that sometimes people say that when a person dies they go to heaven because it makes them feel better. But I was very careful to tell her that heaven was not a real place, and that the person didn’t “go” somewhere, they died. She accepted this and said she understood – I don’t think she did really. I don’t think she can grasp the finality of death at her age. I do feel that I’ve introduced the idea to her though, and I will continue to reiterate the idea of heaven being just another word for death, and that it isn’t a real place.

Maybe you think it’s tough love for me to be this honest with such a young child. I disagree. I think it is loving, and responsible for me to be honest and open with my children about these tough topics, and to treat them like the smart little people they are. They are intelligent enough to understand, and I respect them more by telling them the truth.


This entry was posted in atheist, not real, Uncategorized and tagged , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

6 Responses to Is It Tough Love?

  1. AthenaC says:

    I think it’s great that you tell your kids what you actually think about the tough topics. How do we expect kids to grow up into adults that can handle tough truths if we sugarcoat and lie to them as kids?


  2. aschlady says:

    I don’t think this is too tough at all. Good job mom!


  3. MC says:

    How do you know Heaven does not exist? Isn’t telling your child that heaven does not exist stifling her ability to make her own decisions about the subject? It sounds like you are raising a very close-minded child.


    • AmandaM says:

      I’m all for discussing different schools of thought with regards to religion with her once she’s old enough to understand. For now, I’m going to tell her there is no heaven because there is absolutely zero evidence of it, and when she asks me about it, I’ll have an honest discussion. I don’t think teaching her to think critically and look for evidence is in any way close-minded.


  4. Steve says:

    I have often heard the most honest answer is “we don’t know Some people believe A while other people believe B.”

    Why not take that approach?


    • AmandaM says:

      Honestly, sometimes I do. It depends on the question or topic, and as she gets older and we can discuss it, that is what I will tell her. But at this age kids are so literal, that we really can’t have that kind of discussion yet. She will likely want to know why some people believe one thing and some believe another. Very tough with a 5 year old.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s